UTS student Ayusha Dahal reflects on how she chose to study Forensic Science and its misrepresentation in mainstream media.
As an impressionable teenager, I loved a good murder mystery! One of my favourite shows on TV was Crime Scene Investigation (CSI). The original show and its spin-offs showed a glamourous approach to Forensic Science that was dramatic and addicting. Each episode would introduce a new crime, and by the end of the episode, the crime was solved, all traces were tested, and loose ends were tied up neatly in the final act. There was no denying it - I was captivated! It made me realise that becoming a Forensic Scientist was what I wanted to do in life.
Now fast-forward to my first year at UTS studying Forensic Science. I was armed with preconceptions of what Forensic Science was like based on its representation in the mainstream media. In my first few weeks of classes, I learned the reality of studying Forensic Science. Lab work was not glamorous, test results were not instant, DNA was not always conveniently left at the scene, and crimes were not easy to solve. I was devastated and confused. I had fallen for the CSI effect!
What is the CSI effect?
The CSI effect is the unrealistic expectation of the jurors (members of the public) about forensic evidence presented in a criminal case due to the fictionalisation of forensics in TV shows. However, shows like CSI have altered the public’s perception of scientific evidence relevant to a crime. This means jurors are less likely to convict someone without the presence of some sort of forensic evidence when it is not always available.
As crime TV shows and other related forms of entertainment have become more popular, the CSI effect has become a big problem and we are seeing the real-life consequences. However, it’s not all bad news! Students like myself are seriously considering a career in Forensic Science based on their interest in the field.
In my first few weeks of classes, I had discovered the real world of Forensic Science, which is much broader and more profound than what you see on the screen. I’m still studying in the field as I am currently completing a PhD in Forensic Biology at UTS.
One thing is for sure, the unique blend of science, crime and law will forever be seductive to me and the public. I am a self-proclaimed victim of the CSI effect. Still, I would have to say that learning the reality of being a Forensic Scientist has only made me love it even more.
Learn more about the UTS Bachelor of Forensic Science